Photoshop is not cheating
November 2nd, 2008 by bennyI’ve recently (tried to) pick up photography1 again. One thing that has always been a big deal to a lot of people is that I photoshop my photos. It seems like people find it disingenuous that I do, but I think it’s a necessary part of photography. Why? Because:
- No matter what you do, the camera will not produce what you perceive in real life.
- As with any form of art, I believe it is created to evoke emotion
Take, for example, a photo that a few people have particularly liked2.

Now, what did the original, straight-out-of-the-camera image look like?

World of difference right? What I guess many people don’t quite know is that no matter how good you are and how much time you spend changing the settings on your camera, there’s no way to create the first photo straight from the camera. It’s just a simple limitation on the technology. Even with film, there are a lot of things you can’t do unless you do some post-processing in the darkroom.
And even if it could come close, personally I think a photo should convey something. Capturing the moment isn’t merely capturing the image of it, but the emotion and the power of the image. In the above example, bringing out the contrast in the sky emphasizes the gloominess of the photo and of the scene.
Now, when photoshopping someone/something into or out of a photo, that’s where I feel it starts to break down and becomes disigenuous. Even then, it depends on the extent and purpose of it.
Anywho, if you want to see how I got from the second photo to the first, I’ve created a screencast here: http://www.vimeo.com/2130347
I’ve also embedded the video below. (There’s no audio, in case you’re wondering!)
How I Photoshop from benny on Vimeo.